Amish ShooFly Pie – Classic Molasses Crumb Pie Recipe

Name: Amish ShooFly Pie – Classic Molasses Crumb Pie Recipe
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 35 min
Total time: 50 min
Yield: 6-8 servings
Cuisine: Amish
Ingredients: Unbleached heirloom stone-ground flour; Sweet cream farm butter; Pure cane sugar & spices; Farm fresh country eggs

By Ruthie | Authentic Amish Heritage Cooking

Amish ShooFly Pie – Classic Molasses Crumb Pie Recipe - Authentic Amish Baking Recipe

Recipe Overview

This authentic Amish ShooFly Pie – Classic Molasses Crumb Pie Recipe honors time-tested plain culinary heritage, bringing honest kitchen comfort and wholesome homestead nourishment to your table. Prepared with simple, pure ingredients and slow-simmered care, this traditional family classic delivers timeless flavor straight from the hearth. Discover how easy it is to create this beloved country favorite for your loved ones today.

Ingredients Overview

Unbleached heirloom stone-ground flour
Sweet cream farm butter
Pure cane sugar & spices
Farm fresh country eggs

Part of the Dessert & Baking Recipes Pillar Guide

Explore more companion recipes in our Dessert & Baking Recipes collection.